Toyota Tundra Recall: Airbag Cutoff Switch
#1
Toyota Tundra Recall: Airbag Cutoff Switch
Well, its official. The 03-05 Tundra is being recalled so that Toyota can comply with a law that says all vehicles with a passenger airbag cutoff switch must also be equipped with the LATCH system for baby seats.
Basically, if you own a Tundra you are expected to take it into the dealer so they can bypass your cutoff switch so you will not be able to deactivate your passenger-side airbag. Seriously?
When Tundra owners bought their truck they already new it was not LATCH-equipped, so I'm guessing that only a small percentage actually put a babyseat into the front passenger compartment. Why would ANYONE actually take their trucks in to the have the switch wires yanked out? Very silly.
Not only that, but the estimated cost to Toyota is $16 million! I don't think so. They figure that every Tundra will take two hours to fix at a cost of $100/hr for two hours. I don't see why this would take more than 30 minutes, and labor rates are rarely $100/hr at a Toyota dealership... try half of that.
Basically, if you own a Tundra you are expected to take it into the dealer so they can bypass your cutoff switch so you will not be able to deactivate your passenger-side airbag. Seriously?
When Tundra owners bought their truck they already new it was not LATCH-equipped, so I'm guessing that only a small percentage actually put a babyseat into the front passenger compartment. Why would ANYONE actually take their trucks in to the have the switch wires yanked out? Very silly.
Not only that, but the estimated cost to Toyota is $16 million! I don't think so. They figure that every Tundra will take two hours to fix at a cost of $100/hr for two hours. I don't see why this would take more than 30 minutes, and labor rates are rarely $100/hr at a Toyota dealership... try half of that.
http://www.detnews.com/apps/pbcs.dll...607100330/1148
Toyota to recall Tundra air bags
To comply with U.S. child safety rule, front passenger switch will be disabled, not replaced.
David Shepardson / Detroit News Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON -- Toyota Motor Corp. will spend millions to deactivate front-seat passenger air bag cut-off switches in nearly 160,000 Tundra pickups to avoid having to install a costlier child safety seat anchoring system.
The Japanese automaker is taking the action after the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration on June 28 rejected Toyota's petition to waive a federal safety regulation that requires most vehicles built after September 2002 and equipped with the cut-off switch to also have a child seat anchor system known as LATCH -- lower anchorages and tethers for children.
The regulation was meant to ensure that child seats stay in place in a crash, especially in vehicles with smaller rear seating, such as pickups.
At the time the regulation was adopted, 600 children under 5 were killed every year in auto crashes and another 70,000 were injured.
Children are at high risk of death or injury from airbags that deploy. That's why child seats aren't allowed in front seats that don't have an airbag cut-off switch, which activates the airbag only if it senses an adult is in the passenger seat.
Deactivating the switch means the air bag will always deploy, making it unsafe to ever put a child in the front seat.
Toyota will voluntarily recall the pickups, beginning in mid-September, after completing engineering of the parts to deactivate the air bag cut-off switch, spokesman Bill Kwong said Friday.
"We always recommend that child seats are used in the rear, as children are safest there," Kwong said.
Owners will get notice of the recall in September, he said.
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety said Toyota shouldn't be allowed to simply deactivate the switches.
Toyota's failure to provide the latches "is not merely an incidental statistical artifact but a clear and present danger to the children who ride in child restraints in the front passenger seats of those vehicles," said Henry Jasny, general counsel for the Washington-based group.
Kwong said there may have been some engineering issues that make it impractical to add the latches.
He said the exact cost of the recall isn't known -- only that the fix is expected to require two hours of labor.
At more than $100 for labor, it could cost more than $16 million if all vehicles are serviced, he said.
It isn't known what the parts will cost since they are still being designed, he said.
In its ruling, NHTSA took no position on whether Toyota could comply by simply deactivating the switches.
Kwong said beginning in the 2006 model year, Toyota deactivated its front passenger air bag cut-off switch to satisfy the regulations.
In June 2005, Toyota acknowledged that 156,555 Tundras from the 2003-05 model years didn't comply with the child seat anchor safety regulation.
The automaker asked the NHTSA to waive the regulation and spent more than a year trying to convince the agency it wasn't required to install child-seat anchoring systems.
Toyota noted that it hadn't received any customer complaints and that there were no injuries reported as a result of the lack of the anchoring system in the front seats of the trucks. Tundras have compliant child safety latches in rear seats.
"However, the fact does not render the absence of the anchorages in the front seats inconsequential," NHTSA chief Nicole Nason said in a June 28 notice.
Small children's safety "depends on proper installation of the child restraint systems in which they ride."
The NHTSA also noted that parents with vehicles built before 2002 who mistakenly believed their vehicles complied with the regulation have "used seat belt latch plates, drilled holes through the nylon webbing of the seat belt" in an effort to use the front seat.
Toyota to recall Tundra air bags
To comply with U.S. child safety rule, front passenger switch will be disabled, not replaced.
David Shepardson / Detroit News Washington Bureau
WASHINGTON -- Toyota Motor Corp. will spend millions to deactivate front-seat passenger air bag cut-off switches in nearly 160,000 Tundra pickups to avoid having to install a costlier child safety seat anchoring system.
The Japanese automaker is taking the action after the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration on June 28 rejected Toyota's petition to waive a federal safety regulation that requires most vehicles built after September 2002 and equipped with the cut-off switch to also have a child seat anchor system known as LATCH -- lower anchorages and tethers for children.
The regulation was meant to ensure that child seats stay in place in a crash, especially in vehicles with smaller rear seating, such as pickups.
At the time the regulation was adopted, 600 children under 5 were killed every year in auto crashes and another 70,000 were injured.
Children are at high risk of death or injury from airbags that deploy. That's why child seats aren't allowed in front seats that don't have an airbag cut-off switch, which activates the airbag only if it senses an adult is in the passenger seat.
Deactivating the switch means the air bag will always deploy, making it unsafe to ever put a child in the front seat.
Toyota will voluntarily recall the pickups, beginning in mid-September, after completing engineering of the parts to deactivate the air bag cut-off switch, spokesman Bill Kwong said Friday.
"We always recommend that child seats are used in the rear, as children are safest there," Kwong said.
Owners will get notice of the recall in September, he said.
Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety said Toyota shouldn't be allowed to simply deactivate the switches.
Toyota's failure to provide the latches "is not merely an incidental statistical artifact but a clear and present danger to the children who ride in child restraints in the front passenger seats of those vehicles," said Henry Jasny, general counsel for the Washington-based group.
Kwong said there may have been some engineering issues that make it impractical to add the latches.
He said the exact cost of the recall isn't known -- only that the fix is expected to require two hours of labor.
At more than $100 for labor, it could cost more than $16 million if all vehicles are serviced, he said.
It isn't known what the parts will cost since they are still being designed, he said.
In its ruling, NHTSA took no position on whether Toyota could comply by simply deactivating the switches.
Kwong said beginning in the 2006 model year, Toyota deactivated its front passenger air bag cut-off switch to satisfy the regulations.
In June 2005, Toyota acknowledged that 156,555 Tundras from the 2003-05 model years didn't comply with the child seat anchor safety regulation.
The automaker asked the NHTSA to waive the regulation and spent more than a year trying to convince the agency it wasn't required to install child-seat anchoring systems.
Toyota noted that it hadn't received any customer complaints and that there were no injuries reported as a result of the lack of the anchoring system in the front seats of the trucks. Tundras have compliant child safety latches in rear seats.
"However, the fact does not render the absence of the anchorages in the front seats inconsequential," NHTSA chief Nicole Nason said in a June 28 notice.
Small children's safety "depends on proper installation of the child restraint systems in which they ride."
The NHTSA also noted that parents with vehicles built before 2002 who mistakenly believed their vehicles complied with the regulation have "used seat belt latch plates, drilled holes through the nylon webbing of the seat belt" in an effort to use the front seat.
#3
The LATCH system is very handy, that's for sure. But a child seat can still be installed properly with a seatbelt if the person takes the time to do it correctly. Plus, what about booster seats (for older toddlers 40 lbs and up) that are designed to be used with seat belts and don't use the LATCH system? If the airbag can no longer be deactivated, I would be hesitant to allow my child to ride in the vehicle....yet there may be times where I have no choice.
There's no way in the world I'd take my Tundra in....well if I had one, that is.
Back off Big Brother!
There's no way in the world I'd take my Tundra in....well if I had one, that is.
Back off Big Brother!
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
fur_pig
Scion tC 1G ICE & Interior
1
01-27-2015 01:52 PM
Beesh
Scion xA/xB 1st-Gen ICE & Interior
3
01-09-2015 07:30 PM