Are they the same finish.. graphite?
Part number 42611-21170.
The reason I am asking is that I'd like to order another factory wheel, and found this one ar McGeorge


Here's the description:
17 x 7 Toyota Scion TC Stock Factory Alloy Wheel
Bolt Pattern 5 X 100mm 45mm offset
6 Double ( Open ) Spoke w/ Exposed lugs Design
Brilliant Silver ( Super Chrome ) Surface Finish

I've never seen a brilliant silver wheel, just graphite finish.... is this one the same as a stock wheel?

 

The stock wheel color for 05 and 06 is the Brilliant Silver which has the "graphite" look you are referring to.