Lowering
#23
Originally Posted by stankubrick
Originally Posted by Al.Truistic
OK.....ummmm
What's the diff, are the Spy's and Goldlines's lower rate than Tein, so that they "ride excellent?" Does that meant they ride more like a Towncar or even close? :?
What's the diff, are the Spy's and Goldlines's lower rate than Tein, so that they "ride excellent?" Does that meant they ride more like a Towncar or even close? :?
spring rates = Front/Rear:
KGMM DR21 = 2.2-3.8/1.1-4.4
KGMM NP21 = 1.7-3/1-3.7
Goldline = 3.3/3.4 (front linear/rear progressive)
Tein S. Tech = 2.6/3.2
Tein H. Tech = 2.3/3.2
Tanabe DF210 = 2.8/3
Tanabe NF210 = 2.1/2.5
spy = ?
eibach = ?
(all are progressive except goldline)
By this info, Tanabes should be the smoothest (least stiff) :?
Maybe there are other factors besides spring rates that determine smoothness?
read this about spring rates... http://www.tuninglinx.com/html/a_spr_rate.html someone posted some wrong info about spring rates
#24
Originally Posted by stankubrick
Maybe there are other factors besides spring rates that determine smoothness?
One thing to keep in mind when looking at these specs, they do not necessaily say the same thing. The amount of "progressiveness" can make a big difference in how the springs ride. And not necessarily to the good.
One of these days, we should have a blind ride test of all these springs with the stock shocks. I don't believe you can rightly determine the "best" setup from the specs alone.
#25
I think this is a great idea!
Any kind of rating would be helpful. Three judges and the driver in an xB with the stock shocks and various installed springs.
We'd actually need to get a "course" to drive...
Seems like it wouldn't be hard to round up the rides. Would having sway bars or a tower brace affect this, what about wheel combo? :?
Anyway, would be nice...
Al.Truistic
aB
Maybe there are other factors besides spring rates that determine smoothness?
You better believe it! The shock is more important than the spring for the ride. You can have a soft spring feel "stiffer" than a strong spring with the right shock valving.
One thing to keep in mind when looking at these specs, they do not necessaily say the same thing. The amount of "progressiveness" can make a big difference in how the springs ride. And not necessarily to the good.
One of these days, we should have a blind ride test of all these springs with the stock shocks. I don't believe you can rightly determine the "best" setup from the specs alone.
Any kind of rating would be helpful. Three judges and the driver in an xB with the stock shocks and various installed springs.
We'd actually need to get a "course" to drive...
Seems like it wouldn't be hard to round up the rides. Would having sway bars or a tower brace affect this, what about wheel combo? :?
Anyway, would be nice...
Al.Truistic
aB
Originally Posted by jomo
Originally Posted by stankubrick
Maybe there are other factors besides spring rates that determine smoothness?
One thing to keep in mind when looking at these specs, they do not necessaily say the same thing. The amount of "progressiveness" can make a big difference in how the springs ride. And not necessarily to the good.
One of these days, we should have a blind ride test of all these springs with the stock shocks. I don't believe you can rightly determine the "best" setup from the specs alone.
#26
Originally Posted by Al.Truistic
Would having sway bars or a tower brace affect this, what about wheel combo? :?
#27
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 3,353
From: Holding the detonator
heres a chart that I have showing the Scions i've lowered and what springs.
Scions Lowered
# name color model spring
1 Kristal Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
2 Jason Black Sand Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
3 Denny Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Spy
4 Ernesto Black Sand Pearl xB 1.25” Spy
5 Eugene Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
6 Nuno Camouflage Green xB 2” Spy
7 Anthony Black Cherry Pearl xA 2” Spy
8 Robert Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
9 Vidale Phantom Grey Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
10 Randy Black Cherry Pearl xB 2” Spy
11 Mark Thundercloud Metalic xB 2.2” Tanabe
12 Tim Polar White xB 1.7”Tanabe
13 Todd Black Sand Pearl xA 1.25” TRD
14 Brent Polar White xB 2” Spy
15 Julius Polar White xB 1.8” Eibach
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
17 Eric M Polar White xB 2” Goldline
18 Sean Black Sand Pearl xB 1.5” Hotchkiss
19 Chris Black Sand Pearl xB 2” Goldline
20 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1” JDM
21 Colin Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Goldline
22 Scott Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
23 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.8" Eibach
24 Juan Thundercloud Metalic xB 2" Spy
25 David Black Sand Pearl xB Blitz Coil-overs
26 Robert Blue Onyx Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
Scions Lowered
# name color model spring
1 Kristal Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
2 Jason Black Sand Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
3 Denny Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Spy
4 Ernesto Black Sand Pearl xB 1.25” Spy
5 Eugene Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
6 Nuno Camouflage Green xB 2” Spy
7 Anthony Black Cherry Pearl xA 2” Spy
8 Robert Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
9 Vidale Phantom Grey Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
10 Randy Black Cherry Pearl xB 2” Spy
11 Mark Thundercloud Metalic xB 2.2” Tanabe
12 Tim Polar White xB 1.7”Tanabe
13 Todd Black Sand Pearl xA 1.25” TRD
14 Brent Polar White xB 2” Spy
15 Julius Polar White xB 1.8” Eibach
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
17 Eric M Polar White xB 2” Goldline
18 Sean Black Sand Pearl xB 1.5” Hotchkiss
19 Chris Black Sand Pearl xB 2” Goldline
20 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1” JDM
21 Colin Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Goldline
22 Scott Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
23 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.8" Eibach
24 Juan Thundercloud Metalic xB 2" Spy
25 David Black Sand Pearl xB Blitz Coil-overs
26 Robert Blue Onyx Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
#28
Originally Posted by jomo
Originally Posted by Al.Truistic
Would having sway bars or a tower brace affect this, what about wheel combo? :?
How would the installs be handled? There has always been drama around that... :?
How would we get access to all the springs and how long is the install for springs, could the tests be completed in one day?
What the hell is an accellerometer?
#29
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 3,353
From: Holding the detonator
Originally Posted by Al.Truistic
Interesting...
How would the installs be handled? There has always been drama around that... :?
How would we get access to all the springs and how long is the install for springs, could the tests be completed in one day?
What the hell is an accellerometer?
How would the installs be handled? There has always been drama around that... :?
How would we get access to all the springs and how long is the install for springs, could the tests be completed in one day?
What the hell is an accellerometer?
#30
You don't need a bunch of spring installs on one car.....You need a bunch of cars with difference springs with stock shocks. Then you just swap wheel/tires with the baseline wheel/tire to make each run equal. :D
#32
Originally Posted by randode
heres a chart that I have showing the Scions i've lowered and what springs.
Scions Lowered
# name color model spring
1 Kristal Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
2 Jason Black Sand Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
3 Denny Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Spy
4 Ernesto Black Sand Pearl xB 1.25” Spy
5 Eugene Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
6 Nuno Camouflage Green xB 2” Spy
7 Anthony Black Cherry Pearl xA 2” Spy
8 Robert Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
9 Vidale Phantom Grey Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
10 Randy Black Cherry Pearl xB 2” Spy
11 Mark Thundercloud Metalic xB 2.2” Tanabe
12 Tim Polar White xB 1.7”Tanabe
13 Todd Black Sand Pearl xA 1.25” TRD
14 Brent Polar White xB 2” Spy
15 Julius Polar White xB 1.8” Eibach
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
17 Eric M Polar White xB 2” Goldline
18 Sean Black Sand Pearl xB 1.5” Hotchkiss
19 Chris Black Sand Pearl xB 2” Goldline
20 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1” JDM
21 Colin Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Goldline
22 Scott Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
23 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.8" Eibach
24 Juan Thundercloud Metalic xB 2" Spy
25 David Black Sand Pearl xB Blitz Coil-overs
26 Robert Blue Onyx Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
Scions Lowered
# name color model spring
1 Kristal Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
2 Jason Black Sand Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
3 Denny Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Spy
4 Ernesto Black Sand Pearl xB 1.25” Spy
5 Eugene Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
6 Nuno Camouflage Green xB 2” Spy
7 Anthony Black Cherry Pearl xA 2” Spy
8 Robert Thundercloud Metalic xB 2” Spy
9 Vidale Phantom Grey Pearl xA 1.8” Eibach
10 Randy Black Cherry Pearl xB 2” Spy
11 Mark Thundercloud Metalic xB 2.2” Tanabe
12 Tim Polar White xB 1.7”Tanabe
13 Todd Black Sand Pearl xA 1.25” TRD
14 Brent Polar White xB 2” Spy
15 Julius Polar White xB 1.8” Eibach
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
17 Eric M Polar White xB 2” Goldline
18 Sean Black Sand Pearl xB 1.5” Hotchkiss
19 Chris Black Sand Pearl xB 2” Goldline
20 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1” JDM
21 Colin Blue Onyx Pearl xB 2” Goldline
22 Scott Black Sand Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
23 David Black Sand Pearl xB 1.8" Eibach
24 Juan Thundercloud Metalic xB 2" Spy
25 David Black Sand Pearl xB Blitz Coil-overs
26 Robert Blue Onyx Pearl xB 1.1" Tien
looks like a lot of spy springs went on
#33
Randy, what was this...
did you reinstall stock shocks?
Originally Posted by randode
heres a chart that I have showing the Scions i've lowered and what springs.
Scions Lowered
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
Scions Lowered
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
did you reinstall stock shocks?
#34
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 3,353
From: Holding the detonator
Originally Posted by Al.Truistic
Randy, what was this...
did you reinstall stock shocks?
Originally Posted by randode
heres a chart that I have showing the Scions i've lowered and what springs.
Scions Lowered
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
Scions Lowered
16 Mike Phantom Grey Pearl xA stock
did you reinstall stock shocks?
#35
So all of those people are staying with their stock shocks?
Do they not have any problems bottoming the struts out in front?
I would like to go down 2" with 18" wheels but I am not going to if my stock
struts and shocks will only last 6 months as with all other cars I have lowered
with springs.
I have lowered many cars 1.5 with stock struts and they seemed to have lasted a long time on the stock struts and shocks.
Is the scions shocks made to be used with lowering springs more so than any other car?
Do they not have any problems bottoming the struts out in front?
I would like to go down 2" with 18" wheels but I am not going to if my stock
struts and shocks will only last 6 months as with all other cars I have lowered
with springs.
I have lowered many cars 1.5 with stock struts and they seemed to have lasted a long time on the stock struts and shocks.
Is the scions shocks made to be used with lowering springs more so than any other car?
#36
Joined: Jul 2003
Posts: 3,353
From: Holding the detonator
Originally Posted by k4kas
So all of those people are staying with their stock shocks?
Do they not have any problems bottoming the struts out in front?
I would like to go down 2" with 18" wheels but I am not going to if my stock
struts and shocks will only last 6 months as with all other cars I have lowered
with springs.
I have lowered many cars 1.5 with stock struts and they seemed to have lasted a long time on the stock struts and shocks.
Is the scions shocks made to be used with lowering springs more so than any other car?
Do they not have any problems bottoming the struts out in front?
I would like to go down 2" with 18" wheels but I am not going to if my stock
struts and shocks will only last 6 months as with all other cars I have lowered
with springs.
I have lowered many cars 1.5 with stock struts and they seemed to have lasted a long time on the stock struts and shocks.
Is the scions shocks made to be used with lowering springs more so than any other car?
#37
Guest
Posts: n/a
Originally Posted by k4kas
So all of those people are staying with their stock shocks?
Do they not have any problems bottoming the struts out in front?
I would like to go down 2" with 18" wheels but I am not going to if my stock
struts and shocks will only last 6 months as with all other cars I have lowered
with springs.
I have lowered many cars 1.5 with stock struts and they seemed to have lasted a long time on the stock struts and shocks.
Is the scions shocks made to be used with lowering springs more so than any other car?
Do they not have any problems bottoming the struts out in front?
I would like to go down 2" with 18" wheels but I am not going to if my stock
struts and shocks will only last 6 months as with all other cars I have lowered
with springs.
I have lowered many cars 1.5 with stock struts and they seemed to have lasted a long time on the stock struts and shocks.
Is the scions shocks made to be used with lowering springs more so than any other car?
#38
Originally Posted by stankubrick
This is what confuses me. From most opinions, Goldlines are supposed to be the smoothest ride (not stiff), so they must have the lowest spring rate right? But from the specs, Goldlines have pretty high spring rates. :?
[edit-snip]
(all are progressive except goldline)
By this info, Tanabes should be the smoothest (least stiff) :?
[snip]
They look pretty progessive to me!! They HAVE to be progressive.
IF I get another box I'll sport the tanabes just so I can have two different sets and be the expert!
#39
Originally Posted by superjeer
Originally Posted by stankubrick
(all are progressive except goldline)
They look pretty progessive to me!! They HAVE to be progressive.